Endosulfan in Africa
In Africa endosulfan is used widely, especially in cotton cultivation. PAN Africa, PAN UK and some African NGOs together conducted a study in West Africa over a period of two years. The countries studies were Cameroon, Mali, Senegal, Benin and Burkina Faso. Blood samples were analyzed from farmers and farm workers who work in cotton fields in these countries. All the country samples showed detectable levels of endosulfan. The farmers described many symptoms of acute endosulfan poisoning they had experienced. The study found that “there are striking similarities in the symptoms experienced and in the conditions of use which indicate that pesticide related ill health is widespread, and that endosulfan is one of the pesticides most responsible.” Some of the worst cases of poisoning were found in Benin, which included deaths of farmers or their family members exposed to endosulfan.
Endosulfan in Asia
PAN Asia Pacific (PAN AP) has been active in campaigning against endosulfan in Asia, especially in India and the Philippines. India has
some very well documented cases of endosulfan poisoning in the state of Kerala. A local NGO Thanal investigated the chronic poisoning of entire villages due to aerial spraying of endosulfan over cashew plantations and villages adjoining them in the Kasargod district of Kerala. People in these villages suffered from an unusually high incidence of cerebral palsy and other central nervous system disorders, congenital neurological disorders, body deformations, cancers, reproductive disorders, miscarriages, and endocrine disruption. Endosulfan residues measured in cow milk and flesh in Kasaragod district were over 100 times the permissible level. The investigation by Thanal established links of these diseases and deformities to the spraying of endosulfan in the area. With the support of PAN AP, Thanal campaigned successfully for a ban on endosulfan in the area. The entire state of Kerala banned endosulfan in 2002.
Sri Lanka banned endosulfan in 1998 (and all W.H.O. Catagory Ia and Ib pesticide in 1995) because they were the cause of frequent poisoning incidents. A recent study of the Sri Lankan experience (Gamini Manuweera, 2008) concluded that the bans resulted in fewer poisionings without compromising agricultural productivity.
In the summer of 2008, the ferry MV Princess of the Stars sank in the Philippines, taking with it hundreds of lives and thousands of pounds of endosulfan. The revelation that Dole and Del Monte were given special permits to use the pesticide that was otherwise banned in the country has led to provential bans and an expited phaseout.
Endosulfan in Latin America
Coffee and soy bean cultivation have very significant endosulfan use in Latin America. Colombia’s Departmental Committee of Coffee Growers recorded 155 cases of poisoning due to pesticide exposure in 1994 most of which were due to endosulfan. In 1993, 60 poisonings and one death occurred in Colombia due to endosulfan use on coffee. After years of campaigning against the impacts of endosulfan on farmers and farmworkers, Latin American NGOs, including PAN Latin America- RAPAL, were successful in persuading the Colombian government to ban the pesticide in 2001. RAP-AL is active with local communities and campaigns to highlight cases of endosulfan poisoning and to conduct relevant studies about the environmental and human health problems associated with endosulfan use in soybean cultivation in Brazil, Chile, Paraguay, Uruguay and Argentina.
Endosulfan in Europe
Endosulfan is not included in the European Commision's list of approved pesticides, and therefore it cannot be used in the European Union. In 2006, a consortium of endosulfan manufactures including Bayer CropScience and Makhteshim-Agan sued the Commision, alleging that endosulfan had been unfairly excluded. In September 2008 the Europena court of justice dismissed the case, leaving the de facto ban on endosulfan in place.
World-wide regulatory status of endosulfan
Bans: Countries that have banned endosulfan include Bahrain, Belize, Cambodia, Colombia, Cote d’Ivoire, Jordan, Kuwait, Malaysia, Norway, Oman, parts of the Philippines, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, St Lucia, Sri Lanka, Sweden, Syria, and United Arab Emirates. In February 2008, Benin announced that endosulfan would be banned once existing stocks are used. Nine West African countries have recently banned the use of endosulfan in cotton—Senegal, Mauritania, Mali, Guinea Bissau, Burkina Faso, Tchad, Cap-Vert, Gambia, and Niger. Endosulfan is effectively banned in all the European Union countries. This brings the total of countries known or believed to have banned endosulfan to 57. It is also banned in the state of Kerala, India, as a result of severe adverse effects arising from aerial spraying of endosulfan on cashew plantations.
Restrictions: Countries that have restricted endosulfan include Australia, Bangladesh, Canada, Finland, Honduras, Iceland, Indonesia, Iran, Japan, Korea, Madagascar, Panama, Russia, Thailand, USA, and UK.
Reassessments: Brazil, Canada and USA are reassessing endosulfan.
Resources
- Endosulfan Monograph, Prepared for PAN International by PAN Asia Pacific, July 2008
- How to grow crops without endosulfan, PAN-Germany, March 2008.
- Deadly Chemicals in Cotton, PAN UK and Environmental Justice Foundation report, 2007
- EU proposal to list endosulfan in the POPs treaty, presented at the Geneva POPRC meeting, 2007
- PAN International statement on endosulfan to the Stockholm Convetion POPs Review Committee in 2007
- Press Release: Endosulfan one step closer to listing under international toxics treaty, PAN UK, April 12, 2007
- Speaking Truth Saves Lives in the Philppines and India, PANNA magazine article, Fall 2006
- Living with Poison, PAN UK and PAN Africa report, 2006
- Endosulfan-Factsheet and Answers to Common Questions, Thanal and IPEN [Spanish version], Sep 2005
- PAN International Position Paper on Endosulfan, PAN Intl., May 2005
- Growing Coffee without endosulfan, PAN UK, Dec 2004
- End of the Road for Endosulfan: A call for action against a dangerous pesticide, Environmental Justice Foundation, 2002
- Press Release: An Industry of Death Wins, Center for Science and the Environment, India, Jun 2002
- Endosulfan conspiracy, Center for Science and the Environment, India, Feb 2001
- Endosulfan analysis from Kasargod, Center for Science and the Environment, India
- Endosulfan deaths and poisonings in Benin, March 2000
